When Christians Get It Wrong: Judgment, Apathy & Broken Faith

RSS Feed

SUBSCRIBE:      Spotify    RssFeed    IHeart    Amazon Music   

Monday, November 16, 2026

Christians can be quick to call someone a heretic, slow to recognize their own apathy, and sometimes unsure what to say when someone's faith is hanging by a thread.

But are we actually living like Jesus?

On today's episode of The Steve Marston Show, we're tackling three conversations that challenge how we think about faith, how we treat one another, and how we respond when life doesn't make sense.

First, are Christians too quick to condemn other Christians?

Campus evangelist Cliffe Knechtle has reached millions through his conversations about Christianity. But criticism of his theology raises an important question: What's the difference between defending biblical truth and unnecessarily attacking another believer?

We'll discuss theological disagreements, biblical reliability, and why Christians need to be careful about throwing around the word "heretic."

Next, Sunday Morning Takeaways!

Are Christians becoming too comfortable and apathetic about living out their faith?

We'll talk about a challenging sermon on the church's responsibility to influence the world around us. Plus, listeners share what they learned in church, including lessons about prodigal children, spiritual warfare, discipleship, and the importance of surrounding yourself with the right people.

Finally, what happens when life shakes everything you thought you believed?

Pastor, author, and evangelist Brady Weldon joins Steve for a deeply personal conversation about church hurt, suffering, spiritual questions, and the difference between deconstructing your faith and reconstructing it around Jesus.

Brady shares heartbreaking questions from people struggling with addiction, grief, disappointment, and unanswered prayers.

And he offers a powerful reminder: Sometimes the most spiritually honest answer we can give someone who's hurting is simply, "I don't know."

In this episode:

  • Why Christians are so quick to label others heretics

  • Cliffe Knechtle and the controversy over his theology

  • Christian apathy and the importance of living our faith

  • Sunday Morning Takeaways from listeners

  • Why church hurt shouldn't keep us from Jesus

  • Deconstruction versus reconstruction

  • Finding Jesus in life's darkest moments

  • Why we don't have to have every answer to trust God

Whether you're confident in your faith, wrestling with difficult questions, or simply trying to follow Jesus more faithfully, there's a place for you in this conversation.

About The Steve Marston Show

Real conversations about faith, life, culture, and what it means to follow Jesus. Biblical truth, honest questions, occasional humor, and a daily journey of Helping You Live More Like Jesus.

Visit stevemarstonshow.com for more episodes and a free PDF, Five Tips for Bible Study.

If today's episode encouraged or challenged you, share it with someone who needs to hear it. And follow the podcast so we can spend a little time together again tomorrow.

Sponsored Links

Devotionals

View All